If you're traveling to China, you've probably been told to get a VPN before you go.
But do you actually need one?
For most tourists, probably not — if you already have enough international roaming data or a suitable travel eSIM.
A VPN is worth considering if you rely heavily on hotel Wi-Fi, work on a laptop, upload large files, create content, or have very little mobile data.
For most tourists, mobile data is simpler
Maps, taxis, payments, translation, messages, email, social media and everyday browsing.
If your international roaming or travel eSIM provides enough data and access to the services you need, we'd use that as your primary connection.
In our experience testing connectivity in China, a suitable roaming connection or travel eSIM has been more dependable than relying on a VPN.
There's also one less connection to depend on.
When a VPN makes sense
If you work extensively on a laptop, upload videos, manage social media, or regularly transfer large files, using mobile data for everything can become expensive.
The same applies if your roaming or travel eSIM only gives you a few gigabytes.
In these cases, using hotel Wi-Fi for heavier internet activity may make more sense. A VPN may help you access international services over that connection.
Don't depend on one VPN
A well-known VPN isn't necessarily reliable in China.
We've seen the same VPN behave differently across networks, cities and even locations within the same city.
If a provider itself warns that its VPN may not work reliably in China, take that seriously.
Don't turn “it might work” into “it should work.”
If your only VPN fails, you may lose access to your usual email, messaging apps, social media and even the Google search you'd normally use to find a solution.
At a travel industry exhibition in Shanghai, we helped five international visitors who couldn't access their email get back online through suitable mobile connections. Even people working in the travel industry can get their China internet setup wrong.
If a VPN matters to you, prepare one or two alternatives before departure. You don't necessarily need to pay for every option in advance.
Before you pay for a VPN
Check how much data you can actually use. Some paid plans have traffic limits.
And look at the total price, not just the advertised monthly price. A cheap monthly rate may require six months, a year or more of upfront payment.
Remember that VPN data isn't extra mobile data. If you use a VPN through your travel eSIM, that traffic still counts against your eSIM allowance.
A note on regulations: VPN use in mainland China is subject to local regulations. Don't assume a commercial VPN is authorized simply because you can download or purchase it. Check the current rules before relying on one.
Our judgement
For most short-term tourists, we'd choose enough international roaming data or a suitable travel eSIM as the primary connection.
It may cost more than relying on hotel Wi-Fi and a VPN. But for normal travel, we'd rather have the simpler, more dependable option.
If your work or data needs make a VPN worthwhile, understand its limitations and prepare alternatives.
Don't just prepare a VPN. Prepare for your VPN not to work.